News

Europe is on fire and it won't stop.

Fifteen years after the romance of Time's "Protester," a new generation takes to the streets without illusions, faced with austerity and digital nihilism.

european union grunge war flag depositphotos 191203758 s

A recent article published in the New York Times analyzes the new wave of protests and unrest that is shaking Europe. The current uprisings in Europe are said to stem from a deep social despair and a pervasive youthful nihilism.

A decade and a half ago, Time magazine chose “The Protester” as its Person of the Year. From California to Cairo, the weekly magazine profiled more than 100 participants in public demonstrations throughout 2011: one was pictured wearing a black-and-orange gas mask, while another, speaking Arabic, the magazine “made out the words Facebook and Twitter .”

All together they composed the ensemble that emerged as the hero of the year.

burning money wasting money symbolic depositphotos 829136878 s

Today, Time’s choice seems both timely and distant. As a new wave of protest shakes the West, little of the magazine’s romanticism of public uprising remains. Despair, not celebration, now dominates the mood in which Western commentators approach the protests, as younger citizens take to the streets across Europe.

Although geographically dispersed, the current waves of protest show a remarkable synchronicity. In France, student demonstrations have given way to more violent uprisings, while young people have occupied squares in Madrid and Lisbon. In Albania, the country’s Supreme Court was set on fire by anti-government protesters, while in Italian cities police prepared for clashes with demonstrators.

Unlike the “outraged” citizens Time portrayed in 2011, today’s protesters do not easily fit into specific political categories. On the Left, organizers have distanced themselves from those who occupied the protest marches, engaging in indiscriminate looting. On the Right, commentators portray the protesters as extremists or as young people with immigrant backgrounds who are said to be aiming to dismantle the West — by, say, destroying one luxury store at a time.

These interpretations test the limits of logic. On the contrary, the demonstrations appear as a completely modern form of unofficial politics, characteristic of our era, which is characterized by intense politicization.

Resistant to any attempt at political instrumentalization—whether from the Left or the Right—these demonstrations express a sense of futility experienced by an entire generation. The protests have put Europe on alert. However, given the circumstances that sparked them, it seems inevitable that they will be repeated.

A few months after Time named him its Person of the Year, the German sociologist Wolfgang Streeck gave a lecture in Frankfurt on what he called the “late crisis of democratic capitalism.” In his talk, he described a profound dysfunction. Against a backdrop of slowing growth, Streeck argued, governments found themselves trapped between roadblocks and the bond market, with no effective solution in sight.

Mr Streeck’s diagnosis remains extremely relevant in 2026. If anything, the crisis he identified appears to have deepened even further. After a period of looser monetary policy in the 2010s, interest rates in the West are rising again, raising the cost of borrowing for governments. Europeans, expecting increased public spending and better services, are likely to be disappointed. Austerity – which has never been fully ended – is expected to return more severely.

In fact, new pressures have now been added to the “burden” described by Mr. Streeck. In 2011, European states were not yet under pressure to find funds for rearmament, while hostilities in Ukraine were still three years away. An Israeli-American war against Iran—with all its inflationary consequences—seemed then like an ominous but distant scenario. Climate crises and competition from China seemed more like emerging than immediate threats. What historian Adam Tooze has called “polycrisis”—that is, the network of overlapping crises that currently plague European societies—had not yet fully manifested itself.

The repertoire of protests has also changed. In 2011, ardent supporters of the new social media were quick to label the uprisings in Europe and North Africa as “Facebook revolutions,” interpreting them as essentially digital uprisings.

This characterization seemed superficial at the time — more of a marketing ploy on the part of tech companies seeking to showcase their “democratic credentials” than an accurate description of reality. But more importantly, the term obscured the fact that unions and neighborhood networks played just as important a role in mobilizing people as digital platforms.

Today, this characterization seems less superficial. Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s leftist party, France Unbowed, has managed to mobilize tens of thousands of students and teachers, paralyzing the country’s secondary education system. However, a large part of the protests began outside the official structures of the Left — sparked by TikTok or messaging apps. The same is true in Brussels, where union leaders are struggling to keep up with online calls for rallies. It is important to note that the current generation of protesters is “native” — not new — to these platforms, having grown up on the social web.

Many of the protesters thus operate outside the control of traditional organizations, such as unions and political parties. This undoubtedly gives the demonstrations a vitality and large scale, but at the same time leads to a lack of discipline. For outside observers, it is more difficult to distinguish who is participating and who is not—something to be expected in movements with a fully decentralized structure. Even more organized groups, such as the “Yellow Vests” in France—who participated in the demonstrations last weekend—are loose in their way of operating.

The turn to riots and looting, moreover, suggests goals that have nothing to do with social rights or public services. For analysts like Ivan Krastev, the background to these uprisings is a broader sense of futurelessness — a sense that is also evident in the concerns prevalent on the European continent about immigration and demographic decline. In this bleak context, the riots express a “zero-sum” mentality, where participants consider the creation of lasting collective power unlikely and believe that direct action offers more prospects.

This despair is intensified by a job market where degrees now seem meaningless, as artificial intelligence is set to radically upend the structure of working life in Europe.

While the mass mobilizations of the 20th century contained a hopeful outlook for the future, the time horizon of modern protests has been limited to more immediate goals: increased funding, the seizure of goods. “Tout comprendre, c'est tout pardonner” (“To understand everything is to forgive everything”), as the French say. Yet, faced with such bleak prospects, it is difficult to characterize youthful nihilism as irrational.

Political predictions always have a touch of astrology. Even if it is difficult to imagine a Serbia-style scenario, the current turmoil in Europe will undoubtedly have short-term effects — perhaps pushing French public opinion to the right or turning Spanish voters to the left. But whatever the consequences of these protests at the level of institutional policy, their deeper causes — fiscal austerity, digital entropy, mourning for a future that has been canceled — are unlikely to recede.

And it is equally difficult to believe that the protesters themselves will back down.

___________________________________
Anton Jäger is a contributing opinion columnist for The New York Times. He is a research fellow at KU Leuven in Belgium and the author of “Hyperpolitics: Extreme Politicization Without Political Consequences.”

1 comment

iGuRu.gr
Forum member? Participate in the forum discussion. Forum discussion →

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your message will not be published if:

  1. Contains abusive, defamatory, racist, offensive or inappropriate comments.
  2. It causes harm to minors.
  3. It harasses the privacy and individual and social rights of other users.
  4. It advertises products or services or websites.
  5. Contains personal information (address, telephone number, etc.).


  1. Chris

    “…On the Left, organizers have distanced themselves from those who occupied the protest marches, engaging in indiscriminate looting. On the Right, commentators portray the protesters as extremists or as young people with immigrant backgrounds, who are said to be aiming to dismantle the West — by destroying, say, one luxury goods store at a time…”
    WHAT PROPAGANDA YOU ARE DIEING!
    Seriously now? Do you read what you write? Which leftist distanced himself due to looting? Mélenchon? When?
    Which right wing reacted to prevent the destruction of “one luxury store at a time”? Is this what burning and nihilism are about?
    And to ask in closing: Why do “revolution” and looting have to go together? WHY? And I will answer you bluntly: because the protester and the thief are strong voters for the left, while someone who has created something in their life probably isn’t.
    Enough with your obsessions and the myth that fanaticizes and blinds. Societies move forward when they create!